I had this conversation recently with a friend, and he said I should blog it, so I am.
---
So, I submit my question, why can't a Christian vote Democrat? Of course, the main issue that is put forth to Christians is abortion. Sadly, this tends to be put forth by leaders in our churches. Let me be clear, I am Christian, I am Pro-Life, I am independent-minded, and I believe I can still vote with a clear conscience for either party despite this position.
How so? Well, let us look at how this "debate" is framed. The Republican states absolutely "Pro-Life". The Democrat states absolutely in response, "Pro-Choice." If the silliness of this exchange doesn't strike you right away, let me use an analogy. Say we have two imaginary groups, the Pots and the Kettles. Say we have an issue that they disagree on, pans. The Pots say that pans are "Gray-colored". The Kettles say that the pans are "round-shaped." Do you see the problem? We are talking about different aspects of the pan. This is how I see the dialogue over abortion. One group is saying it's wrong to take a life, to which I agree. And the other group is saying that it's wrong for government to make such a personal moral decision for you, to which I also agree. So, in essence, the debate as framed since Roe v. Wade is the Republicans saying "apples" and the Democrats saying "oranges". This is silly and, ultimately, unproductive.
I also find this ironic because the Democrats seem to have taken the "conservative" approach to government on this point, anyway I digress, back to the point.
My reasoning is three fold:
Firstly, I completely disagree with bringing politics into the church. It seems Pharisaical to me whenever I see it done. Who I vote for doesn't make me Christian, grace through faith in Jesus as God and Savior is what makes me a Christian.
The reason I use the term Pharisaical is that they were religious legalist's. Essentially, the way to righteousness for them was through works. The mantra, "I can get to heaven if I live a good life." Unfortunately, our "good" is not perfect, and that is what God requires if someone is to come into His presence without consequence. As Paul states in Romans, "...we are not under the Law, but under grace." And, "...only though faith in Christ can we truly fulfill the Law." It is a razor's edge between legalism and godlessness that Christians' walk. Is abortion wrong? I believe it is. Is it on my hands if someone chooses to get an abortion and our government allows people to make their own moral choice? I would submit that it's not.
As an example, let us look at Prohibition. This is a case where the government has made a personal moral choice for all its citizens. The result was more problems, not less. If this is too dated, and you believe we are more advanced here a century later, I would submit to you the War on Drugs.
Secondly, we must, in my opinion, recognize that the abortion issue has been politicized. In other words, it's being used to simply divide people into parties, with NO intent on actually doing something about it one way or the other. It's not like Republican's haven't had substantial opportunities, what with controlling congress and the presidency for six years. Has any solution been brought forward? Has a bill even been offered to abolish it? To my recollection, it has not. It's too much of a perceived political advantage to take away. It seems to me they can still count on the religious vote no matter what they do based solely on this issue.
What I would love to see is this issue be de-politicized, and both parties work to make having a baby be seen as a good thing and there be no need to even have abortion be an option. Currently, it seems to be that the problem is financial burden. Why can't the government reward people who have children? Children will one day grow up to pay taxes, so why don't we give money to people who have children and make it worth more then the financial cost of having an abortion? Say, $10,000 for every new child, paid in cash. Certainly a better investment then this current mortgage buyout crisis.
Of course there are other burdens that aren't financial, but why not get together to minimize those, be it education, counseling, etc. so that ultimately people will see that it's more beneficial on all accounts NOT to get an abortion, and abortion will be a non-issue.
Thirdly, it seems to me that the Democrat position is misrepresented. They are NOT pro-abortion, they are merely asking who has the right to make this moral decision, the government or the people. Am I pro-life because the Republicans say I ought to be, or did I CHOOSE to be pro-life based on MY Christian worldview. Is the government such a moral authority? I think we all can say government isn't perfect, and it's hands are most certainly not clean. Don't get me wrong, I love this country, but like anything that is not God, it isn't flawless. Pro-Choice in not the antithesis of Pro-life, in fact Pro-Life is a subset of Pro-Choice.
In closing, it seems to me that this issue is ultimately used as a distraction. I see Christian principles in both parties. One had the fortitude to abolish slavery, the other believes in the Golden Rule. Let's stop dividing on these issues and work to resolve them. United we stand, divided we fall.
I would also like to make it known that as a Christian I believe in being humble and teachable. I need the grace of Christ in all I do, and if I am misrepresenting Him, I throw myself at His feet and ask His pardon.